| E-ISSN | |
Peer Review Process
Peer Review Process
1. Review Policy
SETYAKI: Jurnal Studi Keagamaan Islam applies a double-blind peer-review process to evaluate the originality, scholarly quality, relevance, and contribution of submitted manuscripts. Under this review model, the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the peer-review process.
Each manuscript that passes the initial editorial assessment is reviewed by at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise in the subject area. The purpose of peer review is to ensure that published articles meet appropriate standards of academic quality, methodological rigor, originality, and publication ethics.
The final decision regarding publication rests with the editor and is based on the reviewers' assessments, the author's responses, the overall quality of the manuscript, and the journal's editorial policies.
2. Initial Editorial Assessment
All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial assessment by the editorial team before being sent for external peer review.
At this stage, the editor evaluates:
-
The manuscript's relevance to the journal's Focus and Scope.
-
Compliance with the Author Guidelines and official manuscript template.
-
Completeness of the manuscript structure and required information.
-
Clarity of the research objectives, academic argument, and expected contribution.
-
The adequacy of the initial scholarly presentation and language.
-
Compliance with publication ethics and the journal's originality requirements.
-
Potential issues involving plagiarism, duplicate publication, authorship, or other forms of publication misconduct.
Manuscripts that do not meet the journal's basic requirements may be returned to the authors for correction or rejected without external review. Passing the initial assessment does not guarantee acceptance or publication.
3. Reviewer Assignment
Manuscripts that pass the initial assessment are assigned to at least two reviewers whose academic expertise and research experience are relevant to the submitted topic.
The editor considers the reviewers' subject expertise, independence, institutional affiliation, and potential conflicts of interest when making assignments. Reviewers should not evaluate manuscripts when personal, professional, financial, or other relationships could compromise their impartiality.
Reviewers are invited to assess the manuscript objectively and provide constructive, evidence-based recommendations. If a reviewer cannot complete an assignment or identifies a conflict of interest, the reviewer should inform the editor promptly.
4. Double-Blind Peer Review
SETYAKI uses a double-blind review model. Authors must remove identifying information from the manuscript file when required by the journal's submission procedures. Reviewers must maintain the confidentiality of the manuscript and must not attempt to disclose or misuse the identities or unpublished work of the authors.
Reviewers evaluate the manuscript according to its scholarly merits rather than the authors' personal characteristics, institutional status, or other irrelevant considerations.
The editorial team is responsible for managing communication between authors and reviewers in a manner consistent with the journal's confidentiality requirements.
5. Review Criteria
Reviewers are asked to evaluate manuscripts using the following criteria, as applicable to the type of article submitted:
-
Relevance and scope: The manuscript's suitability for the focus and scope of SETYAKI.
-
Originality and novelty: The extent to which the manuscript offers an original argument, finding, interpretation, or contribution.
-
Research objectives and academic argument: The clarity and significance of the research questions, objectives, or central argument.
-
Literature review: The relevance, adequacy, critical engagement, and appropriate use of previous scholarship and primary sources.
-
Methodology or analytical approach: The suitability and transparency of the research methods, theoretical framework, data sources, or analytical procedures.
-
Results and discussion: The quality of the analysis, interpretation, synthesis, and engagement with relevant theories and previous research.
-
Conclusions and contribution: The consistency of the conclusions with the evidence and the significance of the manuscript's contribution to Islamic Studies.
-
References and citations: The accuracy, relevance, and consistency of citations and references.
-
Presentation and organization: The clarity of the writing, logical structure, tables, figures, and compliance with the journal's formatting requirements.
-
Publication ethics: Potential concerns involving plagiarism, duplicate publication, questionable authorship, conflicts of interest, research ethics, or other forms of publication misconduct.
Reviewers should provide specific comments that explain their assessments and identify revisions needed to improve the manuscript.
6. Editorial Decisions
After considering the reviewers' reports and the manuscript's overall quality, the editor may issue one of the following decisions:
-
Accept: The manuscript is accepted for publication without further substantive revision, subject to any necessary final editorial preparation.
-
Minor Revision: The manuscript requires limited changes before a final editorial decision can be made.
-
Major Revision: Substantial changes are required. The revised manuscript may be returned to the original reviewers for further assessment.
-
Reject: The manuscript does not meet the journal's requirements for publication or has fundamental weaknesses that cannot be adequately addressed through revision.
Reviewer recommendations inform the editorial decision but do not automatically determine the outcome. Editorial decisions are not based solely on counting votes or averaging reviewer scores. The editor evaluates the strength of the reviewers' arguments, the author's responses, and the manuscript's overall scholarly merit.
Where reviewer recommendations differ substantially, the editor may seek additional expert advice before making a decision.
7. Revision and Resubmission
When revision is requested, authors must revise the manuscript in response to the editor's and reviewers' comments.
Authors should submit:
-
A revised version of the manuscript.
-
A point-by-point response explaining how each comment has been addressed.
-
A clear explanation and academic justification for any recommendation that has not been adopted.
Revisions should improve the manuscript's scholarly quality, clarity, methodological transparency, and overall presentation. The editor evaluates the revised submission and may return it to the original reviewers when further expert assessment is necessary.
Submission of a revised manuscript does not guarantee acceptance. The editor retains responsibility for the final publication decision.
8. Confidentiality and Responsibilities of Reviewers
Reviewers must treat submitted manuscripts, review reports, and editorial correspondence as confidential materials. They must not share unpublished content with unauthorized persons or use information obtained during the review process for personal, professional, or financial advantage.
Reviewers are expected to:
-
Provide objective, fair, and constructive assessments.
-
Support critical comments with clear academic reasoning.
-
Identify relevant work that may have been overlooked by the authors.
-
Inform the editor of suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, unreliable data, or other potential ethical concerns.
-
Disclose conflicts of interest and decline assignments when impartiality may be compromised.
-
Complete reviews within the agreed period or inform the editor when an extension is necessary.
Reviewers must not make personal or offensive comments about authors. Their assessments should focus on the manuscript and its scholarly merits.
9. Responsibilities of Authors and Editors
Authors are responsible for submitting original work, ensuring the accuracy of their research, citing sources appropriately, disclosing relevant conflicts of interest, and responding to editorial and reviewer comments professionally.
Editors are responsible for selecting appropriate reviewers, protecting confidentiality, managing conflicts of interest, evaluating reviewer recommendations fairly, and communicating decisions clearly to authors.
All participants in the peer-review process are expected to comply with SETYAKI's publication ethics, plagiarism, copyright, and research integrity policies.
10. Copyediting, Proofreading, and Publication
Manuscripts accepted for publication proceed to the journal's final editorial preparation process, which may include copyediting, reference checking, layout preparation, proofreading, metadata verification, and DOI processing where applicable.
Authors may be asked to review the final proofs to identify typographical errors or production-related inaccuracies. Proof corrections must not introduce substantial changes to the accepted scholarly content without editorial approval.
The article is published online after the required editorial and production procedures have been completed and the relevant publication information has been verified.
11. Review Duration
The duration of the peer-review process may vary depending on reviewer availability, the complexity of the manuscript, the time required for revisions, and the need for additional assessment.
The editorial team seeks to process submissions efficiently while maintaining the quality and integrity of peer review. Authors may monitor the status of their manuscripts through their OJS accounts or contact the Editorial Office through the journal's official communication channels.
Any estimated review period communicated by the journal should be understood as an estimate rather than a guarantee of acceptance or publication by a particular date.
12. Final Publication Decision
The editor makes the final decision based on the manuscript's scholarly quality, relevance to the journal, originality, methodological or analytical adequacy, reviewer feedback, the authors' responses, and compliance with publication ethics.
Acceptance is not guaranteed by submission, completion of peer review, or payment of any applicable publication charges. All manuscripts must satisfy the journal's editorial and publication requirements before they can be published.

